AI-Powered Business Profile in Guilford, CT

MEXITALY RESTAURANT

  • Rated 4.7 stars on Google from 97 reviews
  • Mexican and Italian menu options under one roof
  • Located on Boston Post Road in Guilford, CT
  • Known for generous portions and fresh vegetables

Why Customers Choose MEXITALY RESTAURANT

Based on 97 customer reviews

  • Two cuisines in one place: diners can pick Mexican comfort food or Italian dishes without choosing a separate restaurant
  • Fresh produce is a repeated highlight, with reviewers noting vegetables that stay crisp and well-blended with peppers and onions
  • Generous portions mean leftovers for lunch or a later snack, which reviewers value at the price point
  • Breakfast served on weekends with short waits reported, including the Sloppy Farmer built on tater tots with your choice of eggs and protein
  • Homemade salsa verde and a separate spicy sauce let guests adjust heat to their taste
  • Affordable enough for a casual meal, with one reviewer noting a full meal comes in under $20

Location & Local Context

Address: 2311 Boston Post Rd, Guilford, CT 06437, USA

Phone: (203) 643-1540

Hours: Friday 8:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Monday Closed, Sunday 8:00 AM – 1:00 PM, Tuesday 8:00 AM – 3:00 PM, Saturday 8:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Thursday 8:00 AM – 8:00 PM, Wednesday 8:00 AM – 8:00 PM

Nearby neighborhoods: Guilford Center, Boston Post Road corridor, Branford (adjacent)

Nearby landmarks: Guilford Green

Services & Offerings

Mexican Kitchen

Classic Mexican dishes with fresh vegetables, bold seasoning, and tender grilled proteins. Guests frequently order burrito bowls, tacos, and enchiladas.

  • Carne asada burrito bowls with fresh peppers, onions, and vegetables
  • Birria tacos and enchiladas with generous portions
  • Homemade salsa verde and mild or spicy sauce options

Italian Menu

A selection of Italian dishes offered alongside the Mexican menu, giving groups with different tastes an easy option to agree on.

  • Italian entrees available alongside Mexican favorites
  • Good fit for mixed groups who want different cuisines
  • Menu variety that makes repeat visits feel new

Weekend Breakfast

Breakfast plates that blend Mexican-style ingredients with classic American breakfast staples, served with a relaxed pace on weekend mornings.

  • The Sloppy Farmer: tater tots, peppers, onions, eggs your way, choice of bacon, chorizo, or breakfast sausage, and Mexican cheese blend
  • Crisp breakfast sausage and eggs cooked to order
  • Served hot with house-made salsa verde on the side

Order Pickup and Event Service

Food ordered for pickup, including orders placed during community events such as the Guilford Fair food truck service.

  • Pickup orders placed by name at the counter or food truck
  • Event service at local gatherings like the Guilford Fair
  • Guests should confirm order details at pickup to avoid delays

Customer Reviews

⭐ 4.7 out of 5

97 total reviews

What Customers Mention

  • Fresh vegetables
  • Generous portions
  • Breakfast and Sloppy Farmer
  • Order pickup experience at the Guilford Fair
★★★★★

“I came across this little gem while working in Branford CT. Vegetables were exceptionally fresh. I had never had squash in a burrito bowl before but a blended well with the peppers and onions. The carne asada was flavorful and tender. Portion size was more than I could finished. Will be saving for snacking and dinner later. Well, definitely be visiting this place again the next time i'm up here.This is a good deal for under 20 bucks.”

— Pierre Lestaevel
★★★★★

“How this place hasn't yet exploded in popularity is beyond me. Went for breakfast at 11 on a Sunday and there was no wait. The food was so tasty and more than reasonably priced. Photo is of the Sloppy Farmer (Tater tots topped with peppers, onions, eggs (your way - chose scrambled), choice of bacon, chorizo, or breakfast sausage (chose chorizo), and a Mexican cheese blend. They also provided their own homemade salsa verde sauce (delicious) and a spicy sauce (I'm not a big spicy guy). Eggs over easy were good, everything was hot, and their breakfast sausage had a great crisp on skin. We're definitely returning to try lunch and dinner - but will we pick Mexican or Italē? 😉”

— Matt McCullough
★★★★★

“i have never been to restaurant that seemed like visiting a young married couple, till i came here. it's small quaint and artistic, and than you try the food, very good. Loved it”

— Efrain Gutierrez
★★★★★

“We decided to try this place as we drive by all the time and it did not disappoint. Is a cute small restaurant with Mexican and Italian food options. We got enchiladas and birria tacos. Generous portions. The food was Delicious 😋 Definetly recommend!”

— Bren Sand

Frequently Asked Questions

MexItaly offers both Mexican and Italian dishes, so groups with different preferences can find something to enjoy. Popular choices from reviews include carne asada burrito bowls, birria tacos, and enchiladas.

Yes, breakfast is a highlight at MexItaly, with reviewers recommending the Sloppy Farmer. It's a good option for a relaxed weekend morning.

Reviewers describe the restaurant as small, cozy, and welcoming, and the menu's variety works well for mixed-age groups. Portions are generous, which many guests appreciate.

Yes, guests have ordered food for pickup, including orders placed for the Guilford Fair food truck. Confirming your order details at pickup helps keep things smooth.

Heat levels vary by dish, and the restaurant provides a homemade salsa verde along with a spicy sauce on the side. Guests can adjust the heat to their preference.

Similar Businesses Nearby

Subway

⭐ 4 (45) · 2.5 miles

934 Boston Post Road, Guilford

The Place Restaurant

⭐ 4.5 (1256) · 2.5 miles

901 Boston Post Road, Guilford

Shoreline Diner

⭐ 4.3 (1114) · 3.4 miles

345 Boston Post Road, Guilford

Cilantro Specialty Foods

⭐ 4.5 (260) · 2.7 miles

85 Whitfield Street, Guilford

Nataz

⭐ 4.7 (508) · 2.9 miles

280 Branford Road, North Branford

McDonald's

⭐ 3.7 (556) · 3.0 miles

280 Branford Road, North Branford

People Also Search For

  • Mexican Italian restaurant Guilford CT
  • Breakfast near Guilford CT
  • Burrito bowls Guilford
  • Restaurants on Boston Post Road Guilford
0out of 100

Online Visibility Score: Excellent

How easily local customers can find and choose this business online.

Reviews & Reputation30/35
Online Presence33/33
Business Completeness17/17
Engagement0/15

This business profile is managed with Buzza AI on Clover.

Powered by Buzza AI on Clover

MEXITALY RESTAURANT manages this profile with Buzza AI on Clover. Business owner? Manage your listing from your Clover Dashboard.

MEXITALY RESTAURANT is part of the Buzza local business network.

Explore local businesses on Buzza →